‘Nice’ is not a word that is often used to describe successful leaders. But, it’s really all about how you look at it. This post, from 2012 attempts to shift the perspective about ‘nice’ from one of weakness to one of strength.
My uncle, now deceased, used to have a little wooden plaque hanging on the wall of his den. It read, “It’s nice to be important, but more important to be nice”
I was reminded of this the one day when I caught myself being not nice to a young man who was conducting telephone surveys for an insurance company. Specifically, I allowed my disdain for unsolicited telephone surveys to affect the way I spoke to him. That wasn’t fair. And it definitely wasn’t nice. So I apologized and then did my best to separate my dislike for the survey from my empathy for someone doing an honest and thankless job.
It occurred to me then that nice, at least in corporate settings, is often the victim of our contempt and in fact frequently equated with weakness. The perspective is that people who are nice are pushovers. They lack character. They are spineless, maybe even incompetent. When we ask people to describe a leader, they invariably say things like, strong, decisive, visionary, and courageous. Rarely are they characterized as ‘nice’. Indeed in some organizations we even expect our leaders to bring with them a measure of unpleasantness. It goes with the territory. After all, they are busy people. ‘Nice’ doesn’t get the job done.
But to me, ‘Nice’ gets a bad rap. In fact, it has an important role to play in organizational success. It could also use some repositioning in terms of the way we think about it.
So let’s try it.
What if we decided to equate ‘nice’ with strength instead of weakness? What would it look like? Well, here’s what I’m thinking about that:
When “nice” = “strength”…
It would look like Kindness ~ We’ve all heard it. “You catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar” It’s an old American proverb with an enduring ring of truth. And really, it takes just as much time to be mean as it does to be kind.
It would look like Truthfulness ~ Here’s where ‘nice’ grows teeth. Sometimes engaging in difficult conversations and telling people what they need to hear to make better choices is much nicer than avoiding or misleading them. Often, taking the easy way out is very far from being nice.
It would look like Respect ~ To me, respect asks us to behave like adults and treat others like adults too. There is no room for condescension or patronizing behaviour in my definition. It’s simply not nice.
It would look like Generosity ~ Generosity is often about letting go of something we’d rather keep for ourselves. It is a demonstration of regard and a vote of confidence. It takes strength. And, it’s a nice habit to adopt because generosity can be catching.
It would look like Clarity ~ Being clear about what we need and what we expect is part of the package, especially if we intend to use those expectations as a benchmark for performance appraisal at some point. Otherwise, it’s not fair and especially not nice.
It would look like Empathy ~ Seeking to understand how things are for others is a primary role of the leader. It’s the way s/he “tunes in” to the work environment and engages people, not only in conversation but also in playing a willing part in fulfilling the organizational purpose.
It would look like Civility ~ Good manners are certainly part of being nice. We may think we don’t have time for this. We are too busy. I assert, however, that for workplaces to be ‘livable’ they must include courteousness. People work better together when they treat each other well. It’s as simple as that.
The truth about being “nice” is, it really doesn’t matter what you call it. It’s not about the word. It’s about the behaviour that the word suggests. If we choose to look at being nice as a weakness, we will continue to discount its value in the workplace. We will cling to the notion that “nice ‘guys’ finish last” and keep on accepting objectionable behaviour from leaders who believe it.
So let’s remember those words from the American Playwright, Wilson Mizner, ~ “Be nice to the people on your way up because you’ll meet them on your way down”
That’s what I think anyway. What do you think?